German Sim Mod Foundation

Best Teams to Use in MLB The Show 25 – Ranked by Power, Pitching, and Depth

MLB The Show 25 gives players more control than ever, combining hyper-realistic physics, refined batting and MLB The Show 25 Stubs pitching systems, and team-specific AI tendencies. Whether you’re jumping into Diamond Dynasty, Franchise Mode, or simply facing friends online, choosing the right team can make or break your season.

This guide ranks the best teams in MLB The Show 25 based on offensive power, pitching depth, and roster balance — helping you find your ideal squad for any playstyle.

1. Los Angeles Dodgers – The All-Around Powerhouse

Strengths: Power hitting, bullpen depth, veteran leadership
Key Players: Mookie Betts, Shohei Ohtani, Freddie Freeman, Walker Buehler

The Dodgers remain one of the most dominant teams in MLB The Show 25. Their batting lineup is absolutely stacked, featuring multiple hitters with over 90 Power ratings. Add in Shohei Ohtani’s dual-role versatility — pitching and hitting — and you’ve got a team that can dominate in any mode.

Why they’re great in gameplay:

Ohtani’s stamina and control allow complete-game performances.

Betts’ defensive range and contact hitting make him unstoppable.

Deep bullpen with top-tier relievers like Evan Phillips ensures late-game security.

Best for: Players who prefer balanced, high-skill teams capable of both slugfests and shutdown pitching battles.

2. Atlanta Braves – Power and Youth in Perfect Balance

Strengths: Home run power, consistent lineup, young rotation
Key Players: Ronald Acuña Jr., Matt Olson, Austin Riley, Spencer Strider

The Braves blend raw power with rising star potential. Acuña and Olson provide elite-level pop at the plate, while Strider leads one of the best young rotations in baseball.

Why they dominate:

Acuña’s speed and contact rating give him elite baserunning control.

Riley and Olson deliver consistent 30+ HR potential in Franchise Mode.

Strong bullpen arms like A.J. Minter help close tight games.

Best for: Players who like offensive fireworks and power-focused lineups without sacrificing defensive efficiency.

3. New York Yankees – The Slugger’s Paradise

Strengths: Raw power, elite home run potential, clutch hitting
Key Players: Aaron Judge, Juan Soto, Gerrit Cole, Anthony Volpe

The Yankees are tailor-made for MLB The Show 25’s new contact timing and power swing mechanics. Judge and Soto can blast homers from either side of the plate, while Gerrit Cole anchors one of the most reliable pitching staffs in the AL.

Why they shine:

High team Power and Vision ratings make timing windows easier for casual players.

Judge’s Fielding and Arm Strength ratings dominate in right field.

A deep rotation led by Cole and Rodón can handle long Franchise seasons.

Best for: Players who love big swings, long bombs, and dramatic comebacks in high-scoring games.

4. Houston Astros – Veteran Consistency Meets Elite Pitching

Strengths: Balanced offense, clutch hitting, strong rotation
Key Players: Yordan Alvarez, Jose Altuve, Kyle Tucker, Framber Valdez

The Astros are the model of balance in MLB The Show 25. They don’t have the flashiest ratings, but every player is solid in all categories — making them one of the most reliable teams for consistent success.

Why they excel:

Alvarez’s left-handed power dominates righty pitching matchups.

Valdez and Javier bring elite control and ground-ball efficiency.

Deep bench depth allows for strategic substitutions late in games.

Best for: Strategic players who rely on consistent batting and clutch pitching rather than pure power.

5. Chicago Cubs – A Sleeper Pick for Dynasty Players

Strengths: Young core, flexible lineup, developing rotation
Key Players: Dansby Swanson, Cody Bellinger, Seiya Suzuki, Justin Steele

The Cubs have quietly built a strong foundation for Franchise players. While they might not start with elite power numbers, their young roster can evolve into a top-tier dynasty within a few seasons.

Why they’re underrated:

Balanced attributes across hitting and fielding make them forgiving for new players.

Bellinger’s versatile defense helps both in CF and at first base.

Suzuki and Swanson offer underrated contact and plate vision ratings.

Best for: Franchise mode players who enjoy player development, scouting, and long-term rebuilds.

6. Philadelphia Phillies – Built for Momentum Swings

Strengths: Power hitters, elite corner defense, clutch factor
Key Players: Bryce Harper, Trea Turner, Zack Wheeler, Kyle Schwarber

The Phillies are an adrenaline-fueled team perfect for players who thrive under pressure. In MLB The Show 25, their high Clutch and Power ratings translate into frequent highlight-reel moments and game-changing innings.

Why they’re fun to play:

Harper and Turner create constant offensive pressure.

Wheeler’s velocity dominates under the new pitch meter system.

Schwarber’s Power rating makes him a home run threat every at-bat.

Best for: Players who love offense-first baseball and thrive in chaotic, high-scoring matches.

7. Texas Rangers – The Reigning Powerhouse

Strengths: Championship depth, elite infield, balanced hitting
Key Players: Corey Seager, Marcus Semien, Adolis García, Nathan Eovaldi

Coming off their World Series success, the Rangers feature a lethal mix of power, contact, and defense. Seager and Semien headline one of the best middle infields in MLB The Show 25, supported by a lineup that rarely has an easy out.

Why they’re top-tier:

Seager’s contact and clutch ratings are elite.

García’s arm strength is among the best in the game.

Rotation depth ensures stability even during long Franchise seasons.

Best for: Players who love structured lineups with strong fundamentals and two-way dominance.

8. Baltimore Orioles – Rising Stars with Explosive Potential

Strengths: Youth development, elite prospects, speed
Key Players: Adley Rutschman, Gunnar Henderson, Jackson Holliday

The Orioles are one of the best Franchise Mode choices for players who want to grow a powerhouse over time. Their young stars come with high potential ratings that can easily develop into top-tier attributes within a few seasons.

Why they’re special:

High “Potential” ratings make player growth satisfying.

Speed and contact focus make them dangerous in small ball scenarios.

Perfect team for testing scouting, training, and lineup strategy mechanics.

Best for: Players who want to build a dynasty from the ground up and experience organic roster growth.

9. San Diego Padres – Star Power, But Inconsistent Depth

Strengths: Star lineup, flexible positions, power hitting
Key Players: Fernando Tatis Jr., Manny Machado, Xander Bogaerts, Yu Darvish

The Padres remain a popular choice for online players thanks to their superstar core. However, in Franchise mode, their inconsistent depth can make long seasons challenging without good roster management.

Why they’re effective:

Tatis and Machado deliver elite offensive production.

Bogaerts offers contact consistency against top-tier pitching.

Capable bullpen for holding late-game leads.

Best for: Online players who love aggressive, power-heavy offense and dynamic fielding plays.

10. Miami Marlins – Elite Pitching, Developing Offense

Strengths: Rotation dominance, defensive reliability, prospect potential
Key Players: Sandy Alcantara, Jazz Chisholm Jr., Jesús Luzardo

The Marlins round out the list as a defensive juggernaut. While their batting lineup isn’t elite, their pitching staff is among the best in the league. Perfect for players who love low-scoring, strategic baseball.

Why they work:

Alcantara’s stamina and control dominate long games.

Chisholm provides athletic spark both offensively and defensively.

Excellent for mastering pitching mechanics under pressure.

Best for: Players who prefer pitching duels and cheap MLB Stubs defense-oriented gameplay.